rld和rz为这游戏r吵起来了······

zf19891008

先是Razor 1911的嘲讽

NFO:

        ▄▄???▄
    ▄▄?? ▄▄█  ???▄▄▄▄
   █ ▄▄█████▄███▄▄▄▄ ?█▄▄▄▄▄                   ▄█???█    ▄▄▄
   ?▄▄ ?███? ??██████▄ ????????█▄█???????????██? ▄? █▄▄█? ▄ ????▄▄
      █ ███    ▄█████? ???████ ?█ ▄█████████▄  ▄███▄ ? ▄▄██▄?██▄▄ ?▄
      █ ███  ▄██???? ▄? ▄██?███   ?█?   ▄██? ▄█? ?███▄  ███   ?███▄ █
      █ ███▄██▄  ▄▄██? ███ ▄ ███ ?▄▄  ▄██? ▄██▄ ?▄ ?███▄███  ▄██?? ▄?
      █ ███?████▄  ██ ███?    ███ ? ▄██?   ▄████▄ ? ▄█? ███?██▄  ▄?
      █ ███  ?████▄  ▄███ ▄▄█??███▄███▄▄▄▄███ ?███▄█?   ███  ?██▄ ?▄▄
    ▄? ▄███▄ ▄ ?████▄?██??? ▄ ????███???????  ▄ ?█? ▄█ ????? ▄ ?██▄  ??▄▄▄▄
   █▄ ??????? █▄ ?█████▄▄ ?????██▄  ??▄ ██???██ ? ▄███?????????▄ ??██▄▄  ▄ ?▄
???█???????????█▄▄??███████▄▄▄   ▄▄? ▄▄█     █?????            ??▄▄▄ ??? ▄?
                 ??█▄▄▄ ????█████?? ▄█?                              ?????
                     ??????▄▄▄▄▄▄▄??                   1 9 1 1         <JED>


┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                         Razor 1911 proudly presents:                       │
│                             Borderlands Proper                             │
│                                (C) 2K Games                                │
├────────────────────────────────────┬───────────────────────────────────────┤
│ Date: 2009-10-26                   │ Game Type : Shooter                   │
│ Size: 1 DVD                        │ Protection: SecuROM                   │
└────────────────────────────────────┴───────────────────────────────────────┘

Game Notes
~~~~~~~~~~
Lock,  Load, & Face the Madness ! Get ready for the mind-blowing insanity, as
one  of  four trigger-happy mercenaries, taking out everything that stands in
your  way.  With  its  addictive action, frantic first person shooter combat,
massive  arsenal of weaponry, RPG elements and four-player co-op, Borderlands
is  the breakthrough experience that challenges all the conventions of modern
shooters.  Borderlands  places  you in the role of a mercenary on the lawless
and  desolate  planet  of Pandora, hell bent on finding a legendary stockpile
of powerful alien technology known as The Vault.


Proper Notes
~~~~~~~~~~~~
The usual suspects suprised us again. They not only released a self made iso,
which is totaly  out of place for this game and wasts 1GB more space, but
this time they also rushed their (realy ugly  looking) crack and removed the
"delay import" directory entry, which some of you allready noticed,  loads the
PhysX subsystem. We are realy frightened what happend with our honored friends
in Reloaded! ... .. and by the way the game exe isn't the same as your
try media one. Next time better proof your words...

Reloaded:
"LordPe Deluxe by yoda" statement:
---------------------------
ERROR
---------------------------
This DataDirectory isn't registered in the PE header !
---------------------------
OK  
---------------------------


Razor1911:
->Delay Import Directory
  1. DelayImportDescriptor:
   grAttrs:          0x00000001  (dlattrRva)
   DLLName (R)VA:    0x019840B0  (&quothysXLoader.dll")
   Hmod (R)VA:       0x01BD4998
   IAT (R)VA:        0x01AF4554
   INT (R)VA:        0x01A87554
   BoundIAT (R)VA:   0x01A875EC
   UnloadIAT (R)VA:  0x01A87608
   TimeDateStamp:    0x00000000  (GMT: Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970)

   Ordinal/Hint API name
   ------------ ---------------------------------------
   0x0000       "NxReleasePhysicsSDK"
   0x0000       "NxGetPhysicsSDKAllocator"
   0x0000       "NxCreatePhysicsSDK"
   0x0000       "NxGetCookingLib"
   0x0000       "NxGetPhysicsSDK"
   0x0000       "NxGetUtilLib"



Install Notes
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1. Extract RARs
2. Mount or Burn image
3. Install the game
4. Important!! While installing replace the original exe with the
   cracked Borderlands.exe from Razor1911Install directoy after the DirectX
   installation!!
5. Important! While installing copy the cracked exe from Razor1911Crack directory
   to the .{$InstallDirectory}Gearbox SoftwareBorderlands directory!
   (Not the Binaries directory!)
6. Play the retail!

Razor 1911 Greetings                           
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~                          
Our friends who prefer retail discs!


                                                                             
                                     /
                       Razor 1911   /__   Since 1985
                                   /  /
                                  /__/__

             SUPPORT THE COMPANIES THAT PRODUCE QUALITY SOFTWARE!
    IF YOU ENJOYED THIS PRODUCT, BUY IT!  SOFTWARE AUTHORS DESERVE SUPPORT!!













rld的反击
  Universal SafeDisc and SafeCast Loader (c) RELOADED
   
       10/2009 :..... RELEASE.DATE .. PROTECTION .......: Safedisc/Safecast
             - :.......... DISC(S) .. GAME.TYPE ........: All

                  ▄??  ▄??▄ ▄?▄?▄ ▄??  ? ▄??▄ ▄??▄ ▄??▄ ▄?
???????????????? █ ?▓ █??▓ █   ▓ ▓? ▄ █ █  ▓ ▓?   █  ▓ ???█ ????????????????
                   ??  ?    ?   ? ???? ? ?    ?     ??   ??

Release note:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Since the Macrovision Corp. turned into Rovi Corporation and discontinued
development of SafeDisc/SafeCast DRM's, we have decided to make this old
tool public (after some adjustments).

This tool bypasses checks like cd/dvd validation, trial, online-activation
(for beta games), execution-count and of course silent cd/dvd check (so you
should be able to play The Sims 2 as well). Read the included ReadMe.txt for
more details and on how to use this.

Please note that we will take no responsibility for this loader. We will not
provide any future fixes or support. We are aware the Source archive is
password protected. Do not ask us for the password.

Antivirus software that blocks code injection will block this loader, so make
sure to greenlist the included exe and dll or disable your antivirus software.


Special note:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
We would like to take this opportunity to state our case against the recent
unnecessary propers by Razor.

From the nfo of Borderlands_Proper-Razor1911:

Razor claims that our release "wasts [sic] 1gb more space".
Fact: Our release is smaller. Installed, both are the same in size.

Razor claims that our release is a "self made iso", implying that it is not
retail.
Fact: We stated clearly in our nfo that our release was from Trymedia, which
is an official retail* distributor. It uses another installer that installs
faster, and every installed file is byte-identical to their version, except
for the exe.

Razor claims that we "removed" the delay import directory entry.
Fact: this entry was not available in the original executable.
Besides, a "Delay import" table does exactly what it implies: it DELAYS the
execution of dlls. If there is no "delay import" table, as in our
executable, the inits of the dlls will not be delayed, but loaded before EP
as every other dll. Razor's implication that our version lacks PhysX in any
way is absolutely incorrect (see technical proof below).

Of all the outright lies, Razor claims that their releases are somehow more
"retail" than our Borderlands release (Trymedia), and also recently
SKIDROW's Raven Squad (Steam) release, is the most bizarre.

Let's refer to the Merriam-Webster definition of retail:

Main Entry: re'tail
Function: verb
Date: 15th century
transitive verb
1 : to sell in small quantities directly to the ultimate consumer

The online distributable versions of games are the same product, the same
files, but sold by an online retailer with an official distribution deal
with the publisher and sold directly to the ultimate customer. What exactly
is less than retail about that? The "retail" rule was always meant as a way
to distinguish the final version of a game from unfinished betas and review
copies. It was never meant to limit releases to physical boxed store copies.
Especially in a time and age where digital distribution is becoming more
and more regular and some titles (for instance Saw) are exclusively
distributed on digital platforms, it seems outdated to disallow releasing
such titles altogether. And we know that Razor knows this, because
they too have released titles from such sources.

In the case of Borderlands the only difference with the Razor "retail"
version and our version is that the Razor version, ironically, requires you
to allow the installer to go online during installation. If the Securom
internet date-check at the end of the installation fails, it uninstalls the
game. The installer also launches the game, and if the disc-check fails
(which it will due to Razor's "self made" iso), it will also roll back the
installation. Razor tried to 'fix' this, by creating a fake executable that
should be copied over during the installation to prevent the installer from
automatically uninstalling the game. How "retail" is that solution ?

Another example is the release of A-Train 8. Here a downloaded installer
placed on a "self made iso" was good enough for Razor. And in the ultimate
act of hypocrisy, they nuked a legitimate proper that pointed out that their
release crashed due to badly copied code from a trial version of the game,
something they regularly accuse others of.

As it looks, the reasons for Razor's odd behaviour and unneeded propers
may be an overinflated sense of entitlement and frustration over the recent
inability to win releases in an honorable fashion.

Technical proof:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

00AAD33B  PUSH Borderla.01B2B7C8
                ; UNICODE &quothysXLocal/PhysXLoader.dll"
00AAD340  CALL DWORD PTR DS:[<&KERNEL32.LoadLibraryW>]
                ; kernel32.LoadLibraryW
00AAD346  JMP SHORT Borderla.00AAD364
00AAD348  MOV ESI,DWORD PTR DS:[<&KERNEL32.LoadLibraryW>]
                ; kernel32.LoadLibraryW
00AAD34E  PUSH Borderla.01B2B800
                ; UNICODE &quothysXLoader.dll"
00AAD353  CALL ESI
00AAD355  TEST EAX,EAX
00AAD357  JNZ Borderla.00AAD3E3
00AAD35D  PUSH Borderla.01B2B820
                ; UNICODE &quothysXLocal/PhysXLoader.dll"
00AAD362  CALL ESI

As Physxloader.dll gets loaded the physx subsystem gets inited.

017F6086  MOV EAX,Borderla.01EF13F8
017F608B  JMP Borderla.017F6090
017F6090  PUSH ECX
017F6091  PUSH EDX
017F6092  PUSH EAX
017F6093  PUSH Borderla.01E863EC
017F6098  CALL Borderla.01892882
017F609D  POP EDX
017F609E  POP ECX
017F609F  JMP EAX
017F60A1  MOV EAX,Borderla.01EF13E4
017F60A6  JMP Borderla.017F6090
017F60AB  MOV EAX,Borderla.01EF13E8
017F60B0  JMP Borderla.017F6090
017F60B5  MOV EAX,Borderla.01EF13EC
017F60BA  JMP Borderla.017F6090
017F60BF  MOV EAX,Borderla.01EF13F0
017F60C4  JMP Borderla.017F6090
   
And the above gamecode fills the delayed IAT-Address with its
corresponding PhysxLoader APIs.
These APIs will be called whenever the game calls PhysX SDK calls.
An example of this:
   
Before:
00AAD51F  |. CALL DWORD PTR DS:[1EF13EC]       ; Borderla.017F60B5
After:
00AAD51F  |. CALL DWORD PTR DS:[1EF13EC]       ; PhysXLoa.NxCreatePhysicsSDK


            ? ▄??▄ ▄?   ▓▄▄  ▄??▄ ▓   ▓   ▄??▄ ▄??▄ ▓▄▄  ▄??  ▄?
?????????? █ █  ▓ ???█ █  ▄ █??▓ █   █   █  ▓ █  ▓ █  ▄ ▓? ▄ ???█ ??????????
            ? ?     ??   ??? ?    ??? ??? ?     ??   ??? ????  ??

1. Read nfo.
2. Unpack.
3. Use the included files to run any safedisc/safecast protected executables.

              ▄??  ▄??█ ▄??▄ ▓  ▄ ▄??█ ▄??▄ ▄??▄ ▓▄▄  ▄??  ▄?
???????????? █ ?▓ █?▓  █  ▓ █  ▓ █??  █  ▓ █  ▓ █  ▄ ▓? ▄ ???█ ?????????????



大意
1、双方攻击对方的指责安装架构不一样（两个版本安装完后文件分布以及结构不一样，而且经测试两者的EXE的MD5 SHA-1值也不一样）——貌似RLD是下载购买版，1911是零售版（光盘版）
2、1911指责RLD的要多出1G的要求空间，RLD予以反驳
3、1911指责RLD自制ISO，非官方原版……